Skip to content
PounceFit
PTEN

4 vs 8 electrode bioimpedance: what changes in the measurement

By PounceFit Team · Updated on

Man holding the hand electrodes of an 8-electrode bioimpedance device
Photo: Nicole Molignano, U.S. Air Force (public domain), via Wikimedia Commons

Technical content for health and fitness professionals. It reproduces formulas and protocols published in the scientific literature, with the sources at the end of the page. It is not a recommendation and does not replace the judgment of the professional who runs the assessment.

The difference between 4 and 8 electrode bioimpedance is the path of the current. On a 4-electrode scale, the measurement goes through the feet only, from one foot to the other; on an 8-electrode scale, there are electrodes for the hands too, and the device can measure arms, legs and trunk (Kyle et al., 2004, part I). In a study of 15 devices, the 8-electrode models were generally among the best and some foot-only scales among the worst, but some foot-only scales also did well (Siedler et al., 2023).

To understand what the current measures, first see bioelectrical impedance: what it is and how it works.

Why 4 electrodes on each path

On each path measured, one pair of electrodes injects the current and another pair, further in, measures the voltage drop. This way the skin contact resistance does not enter the measurement. This arrangement is called tetrapolar.

  • 4-electrode scale: two electrodes under each foot. The current follows a single path, from foot to foot.
  • 8-electrode scale: four electrodes for the feet and four for the hands. By combining pairs, the device measures several paths.

Where the current flows in each scale

4 electrodes (feet) 8 electrodes (feet and hands)
Contact Feet only Feet and hands (handles)
Path Foot to foot: legs and lower trunk Hand and foot, as in the research standard, and segment paths
Segments Not measured separately; what the app shows per segment is estimated Arms, legs and trunk measured separately
Use Simpler: step on and wait Requires holding the handles in the right position

The research standard for single-frequency bioimpedance uses electrodes on the hand and foot, with the person lying down; some devices use other positions, such as foot to foot or hand to hand (Kyle et al., 2004, part I). On a foot-only scale, the arms and much of the trunk are outside the current path, and the manufacturer's equation has to estimate the whole body from the legs.

Segmental measurement measures arms, legs and trunk separately (Kyle et al., 2004, part I). ESPEN considers that segmental and multi-frequency bioimpedance may have advantages in situations where whole-body measurement fails, but calls for more validation (Kyle et al., 2004, part II).

Is an 8-electrode scale more accurate?

Siedler et al. (2023) tested 15 devices in 73 healthy adults aged 19 to 50, comparing with the four-compartment model: 1 hand-to-hand device, 10 foot-only scales and 4 eight-electrode models (3 for home use and 1 for research).

  • On a single measurement: only 5 of the 15 devices were equivalent to the reference method, within a margin of 2 percentage points: the research device, one home 8-electrode model and three foot-only scales. One of the foot-only scales overestimated by 11.7 points on average.
  • On tracking: in 37 people reassessed 12 to 16 weeks later, the 8-electrode models and some foot-only scales tracked the change in fat better. Some of the foot-only scales had the worst performance.
  • Repeatability: all repeated their own measurement well. Three 8-electrode models had the largest repeatability errors. The authors suggest two possible causes: the position of the hands and arms, which varies from one measurement to the next, and the larger amount of data measured across the four limbs. They also noted that some foot-only scales seemed to avoid giving different numbers when the same person repeated the measurement within a few minutes, which makes repeatability look better than it is.

The authors' conclusion: performance varied widely between devices, and using 8-electrode models, rather than foot-only or hand-only scales, probably improves the validity of the estimate, on a single measurement and in tracking (Siedler et al., 2023).

How to choose between 4 and 8 electrodes

  • To track the same client, a well-evaluated scale of either format can work, with standardized preparation and the same device for every measurement (Siedler et al., 2023). See bioimpedance test preparation.
  • For segment data, only the 8-electrode scale measures arms, legs and trunk. On a foot-only scale, what appears per segment is estimated by the equation.
  • On both, the result depends on the manufacturer's equation, made for that device. ESPEN asks for an equation validated for the age, sex and ethnicity of the person assessed (Kyle et al., 2004, part II).
  • Do not mix devices in the same historical series. Changing scales is like changing protocols.

In PounceFit, with the bioimpedance scale, each scale has its own historical series and is never mixed with another scale or with skinfolds. To compare with the caliper, see bioimpedance vs skinfolds.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a 4-electrode and an 8-electrode scale?

The 4-electrode scale measures through the feet only: the current enters through one foot and leaves through the other. The 8-electrode scale also has electrodes for the hands, on handles, and can measure arms, legs and trunk. The research standard uses hand and foot, and other paths, such as foot to foot, measure a different part of the body (Kyle et al., 2004, part I).

Is an 8-electrode scale more accurate?

In the study by Siedler et al. (2023), with 15 devices, the 8-electrode models were generally in the better-performing half, and some of the foot-only scales had the worst performance. But some foot-only scales also did well, and results varied more between models than between formats.

Is a 4-electrode scale good enough for body assessment?

It can work for tracking the same client, with standardized preparation and always the same device. In the study by Siedler et al. (2023), three foot-only scales were statistically equivalent to the reference method within a margin of 2 percentage points. To compare a single number against a table, the error of any scale calls for caution.

Is the segmental analysis of an 8-electrode scale reliable?

ESPEN considers that segmental and multi-frequency bioimpedance may have advantages in some situations, but still need more validation (Kyle et al., 2004, part II). Use the segment values to track the same client, not as an exact measure of each arm or leg.

Sources

  1. Kyle UG, Bosaeus I, De Lorenzo AD, Deurenberg P, Elia M, Gómez JM, et al. Bioelectrical impedance analysis, part I: review of principles and methods. Clinical Nutrition. 2004;23(5):1226-1243. doi:10.1016/j.clnu.2004.06.004
  2. Kyle UG, Bosaeus I, De Lorenzo AD, Deurenberg P, Elia M, Gómez JM, et al. Bioelectrical impedance analysis, part II: utilization in clinical practice. Clinical Nutrition. 2004;23(6):1430-1453. doi:10.1016/j.clnu.2004.09.012
  3. Siedler MR, Rodriguez C, Stratton MT, Harty PS, Keith DS, Green JJ, et al. Assessing the reliability and cross-sectional and longitudinal validity of fifteen bioelectrical impedance analysis devices. British Journal of Nutrition. 2023;130(5):827-840. doi:10.1017/S0007114522003749